The other 9/11

This is a cross-post by Twlldunyrpobsais (@twlldun) at Twlldunyrpobsais

When that bunch of cheery medievalists flew their captives into the Twin Towers 13 years ago today, I think they probably weren’t expecting to have some of the impact they actually did.

We all know why they did it – to provoke the US into coming after them, in the hope that the ensuing showdown would force muslims worldwide to rally behind their banner. The results of that we could describe as, well, distinctly mixed.

However, the repercussions of that day have given birth to some weird and wonderful consequences – the continuing media career of Yvonne Ridley, or ongoing national political career of George Galloway, for instance. Or a number of Hollywood movies which destroy entire city blocks in an act of catharsis (but this time, the heroes arrive to save the day, go Tony Stark!). Help for Heroes. Etc Etc.

One of the most transparent recent manifestations, however, has been “The Other 9/11″ meme.

I was raised in a left wing household. An exceedingly left wing household. And I am, as regular readers of this blog will no doubt notice, somewhat of a history nerd. Suffice to say, I was aware of Pinochet, Allende, Chile and all issues concerning 20 years prior to the more recent 9/11.

Here’s my memory of how we commemorated 11 September, 1973, on the liberal left, for the years 1974-2000:

Tumbleweed

No. Wait. There must have been some commemoration, right? On the liberal left? There must have been? I mean, I’m sure there was. The odd concert here. Maybe the odd candlelit vigil there. But I don’t remember the anniversary being, well, noted. Not really.

You know, I don’t want you to get the wrong message about what I’m saying here – in those years, we on the left were more than aware what had happened on that day. We were more than aware of the repercussions of it. And we were aware that many amongst our political elite – step forward Mrs Thatcher, step forward Mr Reagan – were happily making kissy-kissy with Pinochet (We could have a big debate here about how “complicit” the US were in the coup if we wanted, but to be honest, I’m unsure whether it’s worth the effort – the fact that this “complicity” is heavily disputed and disputable in the realms of historical fact appears to have passed much of popular culture by, and it’s taken as a given the US were behind the coup when the truth is much more complex and nuanced, even if you do accept US involvement*). But I don’t recall any call to commemorate the anniversary of that bloody and horrific act of right wing savagery prior to…well, around about 2005. Definitely after the 30th anniversary and before the 40th anniversary, the calls came to “not forget the other 9/11″ quite regularly.

Why did it emerge then, do you think?

A charitable reading of the situation would be that the generation who had been radicalised by the Chilean coup had reached the age where they had an impact in media and they could then tell us about it.

Only, that’s a bit of a lie, isn’t it? The people who had been radicalised by it were in media all along. What had happened in Chile was in media all along. We all knew about it. There was no need to commemorate because we had not forgotten about it. It was a cause celebre on the left when I was 10. It remained a cause celebre on the left when I was 30.

So, you know why the “remember the other 9/11″ thing came about, don’t you? Come on, liberal lefty, admit it. Be big enough to own this. It came about because you thought the US was getting too much sympathy for 3000 people dying in a terrorist attack. It came about because you didn’t like how the US responded to that. It came about because you thought the US was – essentially – a force for evil in the world. And you wanted to remind the world of the evil it had done. The evil like “the other 9/11″. It came about because you wanted to minimise the more recent one. It’s the passive-aggressive ‘Death to America’.

Not pretty, when you look at it square in the face, is it?

 

*The reason I would have the argument, by the way, is not to defend the CIA or the USA, but because it stops us analysing properly why precisely Allende’s regime was so vulnerable to a coup. It stops us analysing where the first democratically elected Marxist government in South America failed, in favour of the Deus Ex Machina of the CIA man. Fine, if you want your world Manichean, with black hats and white hats, and noble Allende done down by the evil US (and, it goes without saying that the coup was not something I support, supported, minimised or excuse in the slightest), but not very helpful if you want to learn the actual lessons of what actually happened.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The other 9/11

  1. You still believe it happened this way? http://youtu.be/YQBlv7sZGVE John Lear has made an affidavit to the effect, “No planes hit the Twin Towers”, this is on top of countless other ‘proof’ that is on the ‘net’. What’s compelling about this is, ‘an affidavit becomes proof in law’ unless it’s rebutted? This affidavit was placed on record in January 2014, lets see if and when, the government reply?
    That said, what where the governments intentions? Beside taking out 3 ageing buildings, what did they want, incite the public? It’s all about control, who is in power, the people, together, are always in control, remember that! The Boston Bombing was another ‘False Flag’, they had a patsy ready to go to court, when Infowars produced evidence, LIVE on air? http://youtu.be/GWA3pp3fqNo This allowed USA ‘Police’, dressed as combat troops, to enter peoples homes without the proper paperwork? Trampling all over our rights. Just like the Twin Towers and Boston Bombing, the UK government did a similar thing in UK, what we call 7/7. But this leaves a lot more questions than it answers. http://youtu.be/R7PQG5weeHk Questions like; Why would a man, witness, say he got off the bus, because he’d reached his destination, when the bus had been diverted and shouldn’t have been where it was? The ‘heroine’ who died later, in suspicious circumstances? Then we had John Charles DeMenzies, who we still don’t know where he worked, but could have seen something? Finally, the suicide bombers, they were SHOT, nowhere near the trains, they were alleged to have blown up?
    BUT, in the middle of all this we have an eminent British subject, one Dr Kelly, mysteriously killed, prior to giving his report on WMD in Iraq? How could this eminent British person, who as a Doctor, has sworn an Oath, to protect life, lie about what he knew? http://forum.prisonplanet.com/index.php?topic=212332.0 To compound the mystery of Dr Kelly, why have serious questions never been addressed? 1. Why was the body moved? 2, Who moved it? 3, Why no proper Post Mortem? 4, Why strip wallpaper from his dining room, while searching for him? There are more, but surely this is enough to open an investigation? Blair and Bush have a lot to answer for, to the public, for their terms in office! Could it be part of the Agenda? After-all, Blair did sign us up to Agenda 21, which Obama has also signed Executive Order 13575, Agenda 21? http://youtu.be/ZosgUqck21c which is something similar to our Lisbon Treaty?

    Like

    Reply
  2. …or maybe because anniversaries urge people to commemorate and not to forget (the 24 March was barely commemorated as a day of remembrance before the 20th anniversary, when it suddenly became a massive event). Once the dust is settled and time has healed some wounds, people try not to forget. There might be some people who did it for the reasons you say, but there might be others who didn’t. I don’t know, for some people two wrongs don’t make a right. They opposed fascism then, and they’re opposing fascism now.

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s